Beyond the Pie at Mehaffies

Pie might be in our name, but there’s more than pie on our menu! At Mehaffies Pies we serve up a variety of homemade desserts and treats, so let’s take a look beyond the pie!

New York Style Cheesecake

Mehaffies Turtle Cheesecake

Mehaffies customers love our cheesecakes! We add sour cream to the base (that’s the New York Style) and it creates a dense, indulgent dessert.

Try our Classic Cheesecake (with blueberry, cherry and strawberry toppings available), Turtle Cheesecake or Chocolate Chip Cheesecake next time you visit. We sell them by the slice or by the whole cake. 

Cakes

At Mehaffies, you don’t have to choose between pie OR cake. You can choose pie AND cake! 

Our bakery serves up Boston Cream Cake (which some people call Boston Cream Pie) which includes delicious vanilla custard between layers of sponge cake topped with chocolate ganache. 

We also make a delicious carrot cake with a rich cream cheese topping. Try them by the slice or take a whole cake to go! 

Haffies

Mehaffies Peanut Butter Cookies

Haffies were introduced at the bakery in 2024, a new take on the “snails” we sold in the past, ensuring any extra pie crust at the bakery is put to good use! We combine our pie crust with butter, sugar and cinnamon and fold them into half-moons before baking them until they’re delicious. 

Cookies

We’ve recently added cookies to the Mehaffies Menu! Try our classic Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chip or Caramel Oat Crunch (white chocolate chips, chocolate chips, caramel chips, oats, potato chips and Grippo’s pretzels). Grab a couple cookies to go or order a try for your next event! 

Stop by our bakery on Linden Ave in downtown Dayton to give all of our baked goods a try!