An Insider’s Guide to Mehaffies Pies

Check out our tips for savings, avoiding the crowds and more!

Become a Frequent Pie-er

If you’re a regular customer, you need to pick up the Pie Club card! When you purchase 12 pies you get one free. 

Discounted “oops” inventory at Mehaffies Pies in Dayton, Ohio.

Check out the “Oops” Inventory

If you see “oops” inventory in the bakery, then you know you’re in for savings! Check the racks when you visit to try a new flavor or save on your favorites. 

Buy our Pies around Ohio

In addition to our bakery in downtown Dayton, Mehaffies Pies are sold at a number of retailers and restaurants throughout Western Ohio. We have a full list of where you can purchase pies here.

Plus, you can add Mehaffies Pies to your DashMart orders! Check out our whole pies and pie slices offered through DoorDash’s grocery delivery service in the Dayton area. 

Watch for Busy Times of Year

1 – Thanksgiving – there’s no better time for pie than Thanksgiving! That’s a time of year we normally see a surge for our products, so we recommend placing a pre-order if you plan on serving Mehaffies on turkey day. Keep an eye on our Facebook page for our pre-order announcement and deadline before Thanksgiving.

2 – Christmas – also a popular holiday for pie! While not quite as wild as Thanksgiving, we do offer pre-orders to ensure you get your favorite desserts. Check out our Facebook page for ordering deadlines around the holiday.

3 – Pi Day – a fun holiday on March 14 every year (3.14), Pi Day is a perfect occasion to eat pie, and we see an increased demand for our pre-orders and in-store purchases. 

Plan Ahead for Special Orders

If you’re ordering pies, cakes, cookies, and other sweets for a special event, we recommend ordering at least 5-7 days in advance. (Unless that event occurs during one of the busy times listed above, in which case check for our ordering deadlines.!)

You Can Sell Our Pies

The Pie Peddler provides a fundraising opportunity by selling Mehaffies Pies.

Did you know that you can sell our delicious pies for your next fundraiser? Our Fundraising Program, The Pie Peddler, makes it easy to raise funds for your schools, nonprofit or community organization.

We provide the marketing materials, we handle the baking and the delivery – you just let the orders roll in.

We hope these tips make your next visit to Mehaffies Pies even sweeter!