Our Menu
Have your heart set on a specific pie? Call Mehaffies a few days ahead of schedule to place an order!
Fruit Pies
Apple
$12.00
Cherry
$12.00
Dutch Apple
$12.00
Peach
$12.00
Pineapple
$12.00
Pumpkin
$12.00
Raisin
$12.00
Rhubarb
$12.00
Berry Pies
Blackberry
$12.00
Blueberry
$12.00
Strawberry
$12.00
Red Raspberry
$12.00
Mixed Berry
$12.00
Strawberry Rhubarb
$12.00
Cream Pies
Banana
$12.00
Chocolate
$12.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter
$12.00
Coconut
$12.00
Lemon Meringue
$12.00
Peanut Butter
$12.00
Sugar Cream
$12.00
Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut, and Peanut Butter Cream Pies are available with whipped topping for $10.50 each.
No Sugar Added Pies
Cherry
$12.00
Apple
$12.00
Specialty Desserts
Half Pies: Cherry, Dutch Apple & Pecan Only
$6.00
Mini 4" Pie (subject to availability)
$2.75
Pie by the Slice (subject to availability)
$2.75
Cookies
$3 for 2
Haffies
$5 for 6
$9 for 13
Cake Pops-Carrot Cake or Double Chocolate
$2.50
Coffee
12 oz bags - whole bean and ground
Seasonal Pies
Fresh Strawberry: February - August
$17.00
Whipped Cream
$5.00
Fresh Mini 4" Strawberry: Feb. - Labor Day
$4.00
Crunch Pies
Apple Crunch
$12.00
Cherry Crunch
$12.00
Lemon Crunch
$12.00
Peach Crunch
$12.00
Blackberry Crunch
$12.00
Blueberry Crunch
$12.00
Frozen Pies
Key Lime
$12.00
Creamsicle
$12.00
"New York Style" Cheesecake
7" Plain
$15.00
9" Plain
$18.00
7" Turtle
$16.00
9" Turtle
$20.00
9" Chocolate Chip
$20.00
Cheesecake by the Slice
$3.00
Single Cheesecake on a Stick
$3.00
1 Dozen Cheesecake on a Stick
$25.00
Cheesecake Toppings
Cherry 15oz
$3.00
Strawberry 15oz
$3.00
Blueberry 15oz
$3.00
Cakes
Boston Cream
$11.00
Carrot Cake
$11.00
Cake by the Slice
$2.75
