A “Batch” Made in Heaven: Sharing Love and Connection with Pie
February 14, 2026
April Showers: The Best Pies for a Rainy Day
April 1, 2026
The Luck of the Miami Valley
March in Dayton is a special time of year. The community spirit is always high as we gear up for St. Patrick’s Day. At Mehaffies Pies, we have been part of the Miami Valley’s holiday traditions since 1930, and every year we are reminded of just how lucky we are to call this area home.
You don’t need to chase a rainbow to find a “pot of gold” this month. You just need to find your way to Mehaffies Pies at 3013 Linden Avenue. We believe the best way to celebrate our local heritage is with fresh-baked treats that feel just like home.
The “Green” Guest of Honor: Key Lime Pie
When people think of St. Patrick’s Day treats, they usually think of green food coloring and sugar cookies. At Mehaffies, we have a different (and much tarter) tradition: our frozen Key Lime Pie. As the perfect, naturally green centerpiece for your St. Paddy’s table, our Key Lime is a refreshing departure from the norm. Because it’s one of our signature frozen specialties, it serves as the ultimate “plate cleanser.” It’s a bright pop of flavor that brings a little bit of spring sunshine to a gray March afternoon.
Find Your “Pot of Gold” Pairing
If Key Lime is the “green”, then our Butterscotch or Banana pies are the “gold” at the end of the rainbow! For those who prefer a richer, nostalgic flavor, these classic pies are the perfect companion to a festive spread.
Our Butterscotch pie, topped with light whipped cream, offers a deep, caramelized sweetness that has made it a Dayton favorite for generations. Or, if you are looking for something light and fluffy, our Banana Cream is a classic crowd-pleaser. Together with a Key Lime, you’ll have a dessert spread that covers every craving – from tart and tangy to sweet and smooth.
A Slice of March Magic: Pi Day (3.14)
While we love the luck of the Irish, we can’t talk about March without mentioning the biggest day on our calendar: Pi Day! St. Patrick’s Day might bring the green, but March 14th brings the crowd.
Whether you are a fan of our classic fruit pies, our legendary cream pies, or our decadent cheesecakes, Pi Day is the ultimate excuse to treat yourself to a favorite or try something new. Because 3.14 is such a popular day at the shop, we always encourage our neighbors to check our menu and call ahead. Don’t leave your Pi Day dessert to chance, and be sure to pre-order your favorites early so you can celebrate in style!
A Sweet St. Paddy’s to our Neighbors
Thank you, Dayton, for making Mehaffies a part of your family celebrations. We are honored to be your go-to source for fresh, quality desserts that bring the community together.
Stop in this week, see our cases stocked full of pies, and let us find the perfect pairing for your St. Patrick’s Day table. We look forward to seeing you soon and sharing a smile across the counter!
