Pies That Celebrate Fall: Warm and Cozy Flavors For The Season
October 1, 2025
Let’s Share Pie! How to Host a Holiday Pie Swap with Mehaffies Pies
December 16, 2025
To Our Neighbors:
You Are the Sweetest Part of Our Day
At Mehaffies Pies, we have been baking in the Miami Valley since 1930, and in all those decades, one thing remains perfectly clear: we could not be here without the wonderful people of Dayton.
The Miami Valley is more than just where we do business. It is our home, and we are continually grateful for the community’s warm, welcoming, and genuinely friendly spirit. Dayton has an incredible heart, one that consistently shows up to support small businesses. As a true staple in the area, we are deeply honored that you consider us your go-to source for fresh, quality desserts.
Know that when you stop by, you can count on us to be open with our cases stocked full of many flavors of fruit pies, cream pies, seasonal pies, cheesecake, specialty desserts, and more! But, more importantly, you can count on being greeted with a smile and a good conversation from Brian, Mary, and our dedicated team. That daily connection is truly the sweetest part of our work!
The Stories Behind the Slices
The magic of Mehaffies Pies isn’t just in the crust or the filling; it’s in the customers who walk through our doors. Every day brings a new opportunity to share a sweet moment with someone. There are a few regulars who exemplify the wonderful connections we cherish:
- The Saturday Morning Crunch: We love seeing our customer who arrives every Saturday at 9:20 a.m. sharp, ready for a slice of our famous blackberry crunch or some other crunch pie that is calling their name that morning!
- Ron, Our Three-Year Regular: Ron has been a consistent presence for over three years. He is such a regular patron that Brian often makes him several pies, so Ron has a variety of delicious options to choose from!
- The Early Bird: We have a customer who arrives right at 8:00 a.m. every Monday, eager to check out the ‘OOPS Rack’, our way of giving great pies a second chance!
- The Chat with Art: Art is another fantastic regular who brightens our day. He always takes the time to chat, picks up several pies for his home, and is one of the nicest people you could hope to meet!
These personal moments - the regular routines, the friendly exchanges, and the shared love for a freshly baked treat - are what make being a part of this community so special.
Baked with Love, Inspired by You
These wonderful customers, and countless others just like you, are the real reason our ovens turn on every morning. The stories you share, the traditions you create with our desserts, and the simple act of stopping by to say hello are what fill our days with joy.
Our commitment to freshness and quality is simply the reflection of the respect and appreciation we have for all of you! We believe that a great pie is the perfect reward for a supportive and loyal community, and we strive to bake every single pie as a “thank you” to the Miami Valley and beyond.
More Than Just Pie
While we are known for our quality, delicious pies, our commitment to the community goes beyond the counter. For years, we have shared our love of baking through our Pie Peddler fundraising program. Since 1996, this program has helped schools and non-profit organizations within a 125-mile radius of Dayton raise over $6 million for their vital group programs and activities.
From major milestones like holiday dinners and birthday celebrations to a quiet, comforting slice on a random afternoon, we promise a sweet treat that feels just like home.
Thank you, Dayton, and the Miami Valley area, for making our jobs a labor of love. We look forward to seeing you soon!
